Skip to content

Ep. 5: 3x CEO Secret Weapon for Winning Add-Ons

Summary

Bill Nunan, a seasoned private equity operator who has closed over 30 add-on acquisitions across six industries, shares his framework for making add-on M&A a strategic engine rather than an opportunistic afterthought. Currently CEO of Lexapol (policy, training, and wellness solutions for public safety) and Executive Chair of Manage America (property management software for manufactured housing), Bill draws on a career spanning roughly 10 PE sponsors and multiple CEO roles in vertical SaaS companies to lay out what separates disciplined acquirers from those who get "sideways."

The core argument is that add-on M&A must be driven by a well-defined strategic plan — what Bill calls a "platform story" — before any deals are pursued. He describes a rigorous process of building a ranked list of 25 to 50 acquisition targets derived directly from a company's strategic roadmap, then treating each pursuit as a collaborative "enterprise deal" between the operating team and the PE sponsor. Bill emphasizes that founders selling tuck-in businesses are often motivated by concerns beyond price — protecting their customers, preserving their team's culture, and understanding what life will look like post-close — and argues that the CEO, not a corporate development professional or PE dealmaker, is best positioned to address those concerns and win competitive processes.

The conversation also explores what Bill sees from the receiving end of deal sourcing outreach. Despite getting 10 to 20 inbound emails per week, he reports that outreach quality has not improved even as volume has surged. The outreach that earns a callback demonstrates personal research, network-based introductions, or a willingness to show up in person — tactics Bill likens to the same demand generation best practices his own portfolio companies use.

Key Takeaways

  • Build the M&A target list from the strategic plan, not from inbound deal flow — having a ranked top-25 target set lets the team quickly dismiss poor-fit deals and stay focused
  • Treat add-on pursuits as collaborative "enterprise deals" where the operator and sponsor play complementary roles based on the founder's persona and needs
  • CEO involvement in the deal process is a competitive differentiator — five of Bill's 30 closed deals were won because founders cited his engagement as the deciding factor
  • Founders of tuck-in businesses care deeply about what happens to their products, customers, and teams post-close — painting that picture is the operator's job, not the sponsor's
  • Set proper expectations with founders before close to prevent "shocks" that derail integration
  • The best add-ons are true incremental capabilities that slot into the platform without requiring platform merges or customer migrations
  • Outreach volume to PE-backed CEOs has increased dramatically, but quality has not — personal research, network introductions, and in-person visits still stand out

Guest Background

  • Bill Nunan — CEO of Lexapol and Executive Chair of Manage America. Former Navy nuclear-trained submarine officer turned software executive. Has served as CEO or senior operator across roughly 10 PE sponsors in six verticals, predominantly in vertical SaaS. First PE exposure came when Reynolds and Reynolds was taken private by Vista Equity Partners (~2006); later served as a Vista CEO leading Zego (then branded Paylease).

Topics Discussed

  • Origination and Deal Sourcing — Bill's operator-led model for add-on sourcing: build a strategic plan, derive a ranked target list, nurture founder relationships directly as CEO, and collaborate with the sponsor as a "corp dev team I don't have"
  • Value-First Outreach — From the receiving end, Bill describes what earns a callback: personal research (e.g., discovering his Maine lobstering background), demonstrated industry insight, or network-based warm introductions — versus the undifferentiated volume he mostly receives
  • Breaking Through the Noise — Bill gets 10–20 inbound sourcing emails weekly; the rare standouts show genuine discovery, contextual understanding of his business, or simply show up in person
  • Evolution of PE Sourcing — Bill notes that PE has become "pervasive" — proliferating into every vertical and industry — and that while sourcing volume has increased dramatically, the quality of outreach has not kept pace

Notable Quotes

"A private equity operator is a professional leader that's been hired to deliver destination economics." — Bill Nunan

"Where I've seen people get sort of sideways with add-on acquisitions... They don't have enough rigor in setting the plan." — Bill Nunan

"I view my sponsor as the corp dev team that I don't have." — Bill Nunan

"Sometimes they're not motivated by money. There are a lot of other considerations or money is one of a subset of considerations." — Bill Nunan

"You can literally instantly get something you can sell immediately, start creating value, but then focus on the integration use cases. But it has to fit." — Bill Nunan

"What cinched the deal was how engaged you were as CEO in the process, whereas I was dealing with a corp dev guy in the competition or dealing with a private equity dealmaker." — Bill Nunan, paraphrasing feedback from founders

Frameworks & Concepts

  • Destination Economics — Bill's term for the growth and EBITDA performance targets that define an operator's mission. The operator's job is to deliver these regardless of challenges encountered — everything else (strategy, team development, M&A) cascades from this objective.
  • Platform Story — A strategic narrative defining what the business is building and the differentiated market position it aims to own. Bill uses Lexapol's example: "We are building the global performance management platform for public safety." The platform story drives which add-on targets matter and which don't.
  • Enterprise Deal Pursuit — Bill's model for treating add-on acquisitions like enterprise software sales: assembling a cross-functional team (CEO, CFO, head of product, sponsor partner), planning engagements collaboratively, and adjusting roles based on the founder's persona and priorities.

Cross-References