Skip to content

Engaging Boutique Bankers

Overview

One of the most common challenges for private equity firms, particularly in the lower middle market, is how to effectively engage the long tail of boutique investment banks — the 600–800 firms that control deal flow from privately held business owners. The firms that succeed don't treat banker coverage as a transactional exercise. They invest in genuine relationships, bring value before asking for deal flow, and demonstrate follow-through in processes.

Key Perspectives

  • Chris Reilly (VRA Partners) provides the banker's side of this equation in Ep. 23: Deals Still Run on Relationships. His core message: boutique bankers have abundant capital alternatives for their clients and can be selective about who they include in processes. The firms that stand out are those that practice Reciprocal Relationship Building — showing up with thematic ideas, market intelligence, and genuine personal interest rather than just asking "what's in the pipeline?"

What Bankers Care About

Based on practitioner perspectives shared on Deal Sourcery:

Positive signals: - Bringing thematic ideas about where the bank might find prospective clients - Knowing the bank's transaction history and sector focus before reaching out - Building personal relationships (coffee, golf, remembering personal details) - Quick, decisive "no's" — not wasting the bank's time - Sticking to stated valuations through a process - Attention to detail in CIM materials (not raising issues that were already disclosed) - Willingness to help on buy-side introductions or intelligence sharing - Novel, memorable promotional gifts that create brand attachment

Negative signals: - Purely transactional interactions ("show me the pipeline") - Re-trading on valuation after management meetings - Not reading the CIM carefully (raising issues already addressed) - Generic outreach without understanding the bank's sector focus or deal size - Expecting access to narrow processes without relationship investment

Getting Into Fireside Chats & Narrow Processes

The most coveted access for PE firms is inclusion in fireside chats — pre-process, small-group conversations with management. According to Chris Reilly, the prerequisites are:

  1. Preliminary indication of value within a reasonable range
  2. Some existing relationship with the asset or management
  3. Respecting the bank's engagement and working through proper channels
  4. Having built a meaningful relationship with the coverage team

The First 90 Days (BD Playbook)

Chris Reilly's recommended approach for a new BD professional covering boutique banks:

  1. Data-driven prioritization: Use databases to identify banks active in your target sectors, doing decent volume, working with privately held businesses
  2. Study up: Know each bank's transaction history, sector coverage, and key bankers
  3. Get in the field: Prioritize in-person meetings over emails and calls
  4. Be personal: Build genuine relationships — get to know people beyond the transaction
  5. Bring value first: Share thematic ideas, market intelligence, and prospective target lists

Cadence of Engagement

Chris suggests relationship-dependent cadence: - Early stage: More frequent, longer meetings to build the relationship - Established: Quarterly check-ins, or seasonally (beginning of year, pre-summer, post-Labor Day) - Mature: As-needed, quick updates — the relationship carries itself

Episode Coverage

Episode Guest Angle
Ep. 23: Deals Still Run on Relationships Chris Reilly The banker's perspective — what makes PE firms stand out vs. get ignored