Skip to content

M&A Process Dynamics

Overview

The mechanics of how M&A processes run in the lower middle market — from broad auctions to narrow fireside chats — shape how buyers and bankers interact. Understanding process dynamics is essential for PE firms trying to win deals and for bankers advising business owners on the best path to a successful outcome.

Key Perspectives

How Processes Have Changed (2015–2025)

According to Chris Reilly:

  1. Processes are taking longer — driven by market uncertainties and a more cautious environment compared to the frenetic pace of 2021–early 2022.
  2. Buyers have become more specialized — a shift from generalist PE funds to sector-focused strategies, with value creation driven by deep sector knowledge, executive networks, and operational expertise rather than pure financial engineering.
  3. The BD professional has evolved — from "teaser gatherers" to sophisticated, execution-experienced professionals who bring real thematic research and understand criteria deeply.
  4. Capital abundance creates noise — with thousands of managers in the market, it's increasingly difficult for business owners (and bankers) to distinguish committed funds from less capitalized players (e.g., independent sponsors raising deal-by-deal).

Process Types

Broad auction: Wide distribution of materials to many potential buyers. Standard approach, but the least likely to produce above-market outcomes for unique assets.

Narrow / targeted process: Selective outreach to a small number of highly qualified, relevant buyers. Used when the asset has a story that requires careful positioning. Access to these processes is earned through relationship investment.

Fireside chats: Pre-process, small-group conversations with management. The most coveted access point for PE firms. Prerequisites include preliminary valuation indication, existing relationship with the asset or management, and a track record of good process behavior.

Buyer Behavior Tracking

Bankers track and discuss buyer behavior internally. Key data points: - Bid history: Did you stick to your stated valuation, or did you retrade? - Process behavior: Did you behave appropriately? Were you thorough in your diligence? - Attention to detail: Did you raise issues that were already disclosed in the CIM? - Decisiveness: Quick, clear passes are appreciated; drawn-out maybes are not.

Negative behavior doesn't necessarily blacklist a buyer, but it weighs on inclusion decisions, particularly for narrow processes. As Chris puts it: "we would be remiss if we didn't mention the way that they can behave."

Episode Coverage

Episode Guest Angle
Ep. 23: Deals Still Run on Relationships Chris Reilly Process evolution, buyer behavior tracking, fireside chat access